This is my final part of my three part series addressing Michael Moore's prescription for health care: Profits of pharmaceutical companies must be strictly regulated like a public utility.
Part II is sufficient to argue against Mr. Moore's point above. However, I want to look at pharmaceutical profit regulation in this essay from the perspective of tamoxifen, the anti-breast cancer agent.
I, Tamoxifen (inspired by I, Pencil by Leonard E. Read)
(information from Wikipedia.org)
I am a selective estrogen receptor modulator familiar to those suffering from breast cancer as Nolvadex, Istubal, and Valodex. Targeting the estrogen receptor is all I do. You would think I am cheap to make, so why would pharmaceutical companies charge an arm and a leg to produce me to help people. That doesn't seem fair.
Well consider all that has to happen in order to manufacture me. First, I need to be synthesized. This synthesis pathway was conceived after hundreds of trial compounds failed to show promising results against breast cancer. Determining my correctly active structure took a team of pharmacologists, clinical scientists, biochemists and organic chemists.
Once my final structure was determined after years of work I need to be manufactured. Specialized organic chemists need to synthesize (Z)-2-[4-(1,2-diphenylbut-1-enyl)phenoxy]-N,N-dimethyl-ethanamine from purely starting materials. I have three benzene rings, one double bond, a phenol group ether conjugated to an amine group. If anything goes wrong, I do not work the way I should. Even worse, I may poison the person who takes me as medicine. Finally, even if all the atoms are arranged in the right order, they have to be arranged geometrically to work. I have to be the right isomer.
Synthesis involves either a stereospecific or non-stereospecific organic chemical reaction pathway (see Synthesis of Tamoxifen). The non-stereospecific starts with a simple Friedel-Craft acylation involving Anisole and Phenylacetic acid. The acylating agent in this process is a mixture of PCl5 / SnCl4. The ketone is was formed in a 78% yield.
Then, alkylation is promoted by treating the ketone with Sodium hydride (NaH). This removes the acidic protons (located on the position alpha to the carbonyl group) to produce the enolate ion. This could be isolated as the sodium enolate of the ketone treatment of this with ethyl iodide resulting in the formation of a compound in a 94% yield. The Ethyl iodide is chosen as the acylating agent probably as it contains the iodide ion, which is an excellent leaving group. It can therefore facilitate an SN2 substitution reaction with relative easy.
There are another four steps of similar complicating reactions. Each one involved hours of analysis, imagination, and work by a team of organic chemists. These organic chemists are human beings who need to be fed and who have families. They need to be paid competitively in order to stay with the company and one day retire to enjoy their families.
Finally, once I am a final drug entity, I need to be formulated as an oral tablet. Since the amount I exist in the final drug form is so small, I need to be mixed with inactive ingredients in order to get to where I need to work in the body. First step is to mix me with filler. Another ingredient is added so that when I'm pressed into a tablet there is no friction on the die wall press. Finally, identifying markers are engraved on the side of my tablet so that health professionals can identify me from other tablets.
All of these manufacturing processes take years of research and time. A team of chemical engineers and technicians guarantee that I remain stable throughout the manufacturing process. They need to make sure I don't degrade as I'm made. They need to make sure I dissolve in the stomach quick enough so I am absorbed. They also need to make sure that manufacturing me doesn't cost too much.
Finally, once I am my final tablet form, investigators need to make sure I am safe. They test me first on animals to see if I don't cause too much harm. Then they test me on healthy volunteers. Finally they test me on patients. All of these tests and investigations require a team of experts, clinical scientists, nurses, and volunteer patients.
As all of these tests are underway, I need to be approved by the FDA. This requires a team of lawyers and clinical scientists to make sure I am presented to the FDA as a safe and effective treatment for breast cancer. Finally, once I am approved, the pharmaceutical company needs to inform health professionals of my existence. Health professionals are too busy to keep up with the newest drugs. So in order to get me to patients, the company needs to market me.
So, you can imagine what all this costs. I am yet not a finished product. I have a black box warning from a side effect discovered after I went to market:
Tamoxifen Black Box Warning
Serious/Life-Threatening Events
serious, life-threatening, and sometimes fatal events in risk reduction setting (ductal carcinoma in situ and high breast CA risk women) incl. uterine malignancies (endometrial adenocarcinoma and uterine sarcoma), stroke, and PE; discuss potential benefits and risks of tx w/ women in these populations considering decr. breast CA risk; tamoxifen benefits outweigh risks in women already diagnosed w/ breast CA
So, pharmaceutical companies need to make better drugs than me. They need to make drugs that are more effective and have less side effects. In order to do so, the profits made from selling me have to make up for the cost of making me so that new drugs may be developed.
IF THESE PROFITS WERE REGULATED THERE WOULD BE NO NEW DRUGS.
Showing posts with label profit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label profit. Show all posts
Sunday, June 24, 2007
Thursday, May 10, 2007
Emergence of profit and loss by uncertainty

Mises writes in Profit And Loss "If all people were to anticipate correctly the future state of the market, the entrepreneurs would neither earn any profits nor suffer any losses. They would have to buy the complementary factors of production at prices which would, already at the instant of the purchase, fully reflect the future prices of the products".
I tried to construct some kind of proof for this. Please look at the above three figures as I explain.
Let's suppose we have a market for rice and sushi does not yet exist. An entrepreneur is considering inventing sushi. She needs rice to make sushi. What price results in the market for rice? If we can answer this question, we can understand what Mises says "the total costs of production depends on the prices for the product" and we can understand what Kirzner writes how uncertainty fuels entrepreneurship.
Please look at the graph on the left. It shows the relationship between sushi and rice in our entrepreneur's future envisioned market. The first curve (left curve) bulging out reflects the production possibilities curve for rice and sushi. If I give up a certain amount of rice in society, I relieve resources to produce sushi.
The straight line curving down is the budget curve. The amount of rice and sushi cannot exceed beyond the boundary of this curve. This represents the scarcity of resources.
Finally the last curve (right curve) bulging in reflects what is called the indifference curve. Please focus on the solid curve and ignore the dotted one for now.It represents how changes in the consumption for rice and sushi reflects people's welfare. Along this curve people are indifferent to the changes in sushi or rice consumption. In the beginning of the curve, you have large decreases in sushi consumption (the curve is sloping down) corresponding to small increases in rice consumption. Yet, there is no change in society's happiness or welfare.
What consumption, then, would society achieve with rice and sushi. Given the production possibilities curve (bulging out), budget curve (straight down), and the solid indifference curve (bulging in), what would be the resulting consumption of rice and sushi?
Point B reflects the amount of sushi and rice optimally consumed in society for three reasons. It lies along the production possibilities curve, meaning it is possible to produce that amount of sushi for a given amount of rice represented at point B. This point does not exceed the budget curve, so society has enough resources to produce both rice and sushi at that point. Finally it is along the indifference curve, where welfare is possible to achieve.
So what does this mean for the entrepreneur? To answer this I need to first introduce the middle and right curves. They show the supply and demand for both sushi and rice. As we already know these curves reflect the equilibrium price of these two products. I know nothing in real markets is at equilibrium, but please bear with me.
How do these three curves relate? Look at the left curve's point B. It reflects an optimal amount of sushi and rice produced and consumed given all the information in the three curves. This consumption is reflected in the curve B in both the middle and right curves.
Remember in the left graph, we only focused on the bold indifference curve. This represents that we are CERTAIN about how the market will value the composition of sushi and rice consumption. Mises and Kirzner would argue in this situation there is no profit or loss. So now answering the final question, how does uncertainty foster an emergence of profit or loss?
Now we look at both the dotted indifference curve and the bold indifference curve
from the left graph. The dotted curve represents another possible reflection of so
ciety's value for sushi and rice. In our scenario now, we are not certain of which indifference curve. They are both possible. So what would be the result of this uncertainty on the market for sushi and rice that represents a potential emergence of profit and loss for the entrepreneur?
Along the dotted curve we see that it intersects the production possibilities curve at two points A and C. For the dotted indifference curve, these are the only two possible consumption optimums for sushi and rice. Notice for point A that the amount of rice demanded is less than for point C. Yet, for point C the amount of sushi demanded is less than for point A. The resulting supply/demand curves show the result of this.
For A, the equilibrium price for rice is lower than for point C. Thus the input prices for sushi production is lower for A than for C. On the right curve, we see that the equilibrium price for sushi is higher for A than for C.
Thus, under conditions of A we have profit because the price of sushi exceeds the price of rice. For conditions of B, we have neither profit or loss. For conditions of C, we have loss because the equilibrium price of sushi is less than that for rice.
These resulting differences were due to the differences in the position of the two indifference curves. In an entrepreneurial setting, we are uncertain as to the view of society's value on sushi and rice. We are uncertain as to whether society's value is reflected in the dotted curve or the bold curve. This uncertainty is what drives the emergence of profit and loss. Q.E.F. :-)
I tried to construct some kind of proof for this. Please look at the above three figures as I explain.
Let's suppose we have a market for rice and sushi does not yet exist. An entrepreneur is considering inventing sushi. She needs rice to make sushi. What price results in the market for rice? If we can answer this question, we can understand what Mises says "the total costs of production depends on the prices for the product" and we can understand what Kirzner writes how uncertainty fuels entrepreneurship.
Please look at the graph on the left. It shows the relationship between sushi and rice in our entrepreneur's future envisioned market. The first curve (left curve) bulging out reflects the production possibilities curve for rice and sushi. If I give up a certain amount of rice in society, I relieve resources to produce sushi.
The straight line curving down is the budget curve. The amount of rice and sushi cannot exceed beyond the boundary of this curve. This represents the scarcity of resources.
Finally the last curve (right curve) bulging in reflects what is called the indifference curve. Please focus on the solid curve and ignore the dotted one for now.It represents how changes in the consumption for rice and sushi reflects people's welfare. Along this curve people are indifferent to the changes in sushi or rice consumption. In the beginning of the curve, you have large decreases in sushi consumption (the curve is sloping down) corresponding to small increases in rice consumption. Yet, there is no change in society's happiness or welfare.
What consumption, then, would society achieve with rice and sushi. Given the production possibilities curve (bulging out), budget curve (straight down), and the solid indifference curve (bulging in), what would be the resulting consumption of rice and sushi?
Point B reflects the amount of sushi and rice optimally consumed in society for three reasons. It lies along the production possibilities curve, meaning it is possible to produce that amount of sushi for a given amount of rice represented at point B. This point does not exceed the budget curve, so society has enough resources to produce both rice and sushi at that point. Finally it is along the indifference curve, where welfare is possible to achieve.
So what does this mean for the entrepreneur? To answer this I need to first introduce the middle and right curves. They show the supply and demand for both sushi and rice. As we already know these curves reflect the equilibrium price of these two products. I know nothing in real markets is at equilibrium, but please bear with me.
How do these three curves relate? Look at the left curve's point B. It reflects an optimal amount of sushi and rice produced and consumed given all the information in the three curves. This consumption is reflected in the curve B in both the middle and right curves.
Remember in the left graph, we only focused on the bold indifference curve. This represents that we are CERTAIN about how the market will value the composition of sushi and rice consumption. Mises and Kirzner would argue in this situation there is no profit or loss. So now answering the final question, how does uncertainty foster an emergence of profit or loss?
Now we look at both the dotted indifference curve and the bold indifference curve
from the left graph. The dotted curve represents another possible reflection of so
ciety's value for sushi and rice. In our scenario now, we are not certain of which indifference curve. They are both possible. So what would be the result of this uncertainty on the market for sushi and rice that represents a potential emergence of profit and loss for the entrepreneur?
Along the dotted curve we see that it intersects the production possibilities curve at two points A and C. For the dotted indifference curve, these are the only two possible consumption optimums for sushi and rice. Notice for point A that the amount of rice demanded is less than for point C. Yet, for point C the amount of sushi demanded is less than for point A. The resulting supply/demand curves show the result of this.
For A, the equilibrium price for rice is lower than for point C. Thus the input prices for sushi production is lower for A than for C. On the right curve, we see that the equilibrium price for sushi is higher for A than for C.
Thus, under conditions of A we have profit because the price of sushi exceeds the price of rice. For conditions of B, we have neither profit or loss. For conditions of C, we have loss because the equilibrium price of sushi is less than that for rice.
These resulting differences were due to the differences in the position of the two indifference curves. In an entrepreneurial setting, we are uncertain as to the view of society's value on sushi and rice. We are uncertain as to whether society's value is reflected in the dotted curve or the bold curve. This uncertainty is what drives the emergence of profit and loss. Q.E.F. :-)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)